Your Web3 Game Does Not Need a Land Sale
Studios keep funding development by selling virtual plots and passes before a single level is playable. The results, from empty worlds to angry buyers, suggest it is time to stop.
There is a particular kind of silence that settles over a virtual world nine months after its land sale. The plots are all owned. The marketing channels are busy. And almost nobody is playing.
I have covered web3 games for five years, and the pattern is now so reliable it deserves a name. Call it the pre-sale trap: a studio sells scarce digital property before it has a game anyone wants to play, raises a pile of money, and discovers that it has created an audience of investors rather than players. Every incentive that follows is distorted.
This is my argument, bluntly: studios should stop funding games with land sales. The industry has plenty of evidence that the model fails, and no remaining excuse.
The numbers do not lie
Take Ironmoss Interactive, a studio whose fantasy-world project sold 11,200 plots in 2024 for a total of roughly $38 million. At peak, the secondary market for those plots traded at three times the launch price. A year later, the game had about 900 daily active users, and floor prices had fallen 91 percent. The studio’s team of 60 had shrunk to 14.
Ironmoss is not an outlier. Of the twelve largest land sales I have tracked since 2023, nine now have fewer daily players than the number of plots sold. Several of those games are technically alive, but alive in the way a shopping centre is alive when only the security guards turn up.
The reason is structural. A land sale front-loads revenue, which means the studio is paid before it must deliver. Buyers, meanwhile, are not buying a game. They are buying a bet that other people will later want to play it. Treating that as a funding model is treating the audience as a bank.
Why buyers and players are different people
A player wants fun, fairness and a reason to come back on Tuesday. A land buyer wants scarcity, rising prices and a shrinking supply of competing plots. These interests collide constantly. Designers who want to add new zones, which would dilute land value, face furious backlash from owners. Studios that want to rebalance an economy discover that the same community members who paid for it will riot at any change that dents resale value.
“The first players in your game should be people who enjoy it, not people who would be harmed if you improved it.”

A developer I spoke to at a mid-sized studio in Montréal, who asked not to be named because the company is still raising, put it more bluntly. “We took the land money and it ate our design freedom. Every roadmap meeting became a negotiation with a spreadsheet of owners.”
The counter-argument, fairly stated
Defenders of land sales make two points that deserve a hearing. First, games are expensive, and traditional venture funding is scarce for crypto-native studios. Second, selling ownership can align a community with the game’s long-term success, the way early backers of a crowdfunded project feel invested.
Both are true, as far as they go. But crowdfunding a game on a playable demo, with refunds or milestones attached, is not the same as selling a speculative asset with no delivery obligation. And the alignment argument has a darker twin: buyers who feel ownership also feel entitlement, and they weaponise it.
What to do instead
There are credible alternatives, and some studios are already using them.
- Fund the build, sell the content later. Raise capital through conventional means, ship a playable game, and offer cosmetic or functional items once players exist.
- Milestone-gated sales. If tokens or land must be sold early, release proceeds to the team only as playable milestones are hit, enforced by escrow.
- Earn, don’t buy, scarcity. Give early players the rare plots through participation, not purchase. Scarcity that is earned feels like a trophy; scarcity that is bought feels like a ticket.
None of these is as lucrative in month one. All of them are far kinder to month eighteen.
The standard to hold
The industry loves to say it is building games first. A simple test would prove it: would the studio still be building this game if nobody could trade the land? If the answer is no, then the game is not the product. The sale is.
Players have noticed. The most encouraging projects I have seen this year are the ones that launched with no ownership sale at all, only a small, playable game and an honest roadmap. They are not exciting on a trading chart. They are exciting at 9 p.m. on a Tuesday, when the servers are full.
That is where a game should be measured.
Eli oversees coverage of token markets, derivatives and unlock schedules, after a decade on trading-desk research teams. He is based in Chicago.
Conversation (…)
One briefing. Every morning. Free.
Join readers who start the day with Crypto Beacon: the essential Crypto & web3 stories, curated by our editors.